In today’s roofing industry, contractors often align themselves with different shingle manufacturers, each championing their preferred brands based on experience, performance, and customer satisfaction. This diversity of professional preferences reflects the strong competition among leading manufacturers, with each brand offering unique advantages in durability, style, and warranty coverage. As you explore roofing options, you’ll likely encounter contractors who specialize in GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, or other major roofing manufacturers.
Understanding these manufacturer differences becomes crucial when selecting both your roofing materials and contractor. Our comprehensive guide examines the strengths and specialties of each major shingle manufacturer, helping you make an informed decision regardless of your chosen contractor’s brand affiliation. We’ll explore how different manufacturers compare in terms of product quality, warranty protection, and value, ensuring you can confidently evaluate your options whether your contractor recommends GAF’s Timberline series, CertainTeed’s Landmark collection, or other premium product lines.
Pros & Cons of the Top 6 Roofing Manufacturers
Several reputable brands offer a variety of options, each with its own strengths, weaknesses, and price points. It is important to consider your budget, the climate in your area, and the overall aesthetic you are trying to achieve when selecting a brand and style. Consulting with a qualified roofing contractor is always recommended.
GAF Shingles
GAF is the largest roofing manufacturer in North America, offering a vast array of asphalt shingles and price points. They are known for their focus on innovation and technology, with features like StainGuard® algae protection and Advanced Protection® shingle technology. GAF’s product range spans from budget-friendly 3-tab shingles like Marathon Plus to premium designer shingles like Camelot and Grand Canyon. They also offer specialty shingles like Timberline HDZ asphalt shingles, known for its enhanced wind resistance. GAF offers a variety of warranties, including their Golden Pledge® Warranty, which provides comprehensive coverage when installed by a GAF-certified contractor. However, while GAF offers wide availability, an extensive product line, strong warranties, and a large network of certified installers, they can be more expensive than some other brands.
CertainTeed Shingles
The roofing manufacturer CertainTeed is a leading manufacturer of building materials, including a comprehensive line of roofing shingles. They are known for their focus on design and sustainability. CertainTeed offers everything from traditional asphalt shingles like Landmark to designer shingles like Carriage House and Presidential Shake, and even solar roofing options. Key features include StreakFighter® algae resistance and a wide range of colors and styles, with some shingles that mimic the look of natural slate or wood shake. CertainTeed offers a variety of warranties, including their Integrity Roof System warranty. While CertainTeed provides excellent design options, a focus on sustainability, and a wide range of products, they can be more expensive than some other brands, and availability can vary by region.
Owens Corning Roofing
The manufacturer Owens Corning is a well-known brand in the building materials industry, offering high-quality roofing products and insulation solutions. Their shingle offerings include 3-tab shingles, architectural shingles like Duration, and designer shingles. Owens Corning emphasizes its SureNail® Technology for enhanced shingle adhesion and wind resistance, and their Duration shingles are a popular choice. They also provide a comprehensive warranty, including their Tru PROtection® Warranty, and a network of preferred contractors. While Owens Corning offers quality materials, good warranties, and a network of preferred contractors, they can be more expensive than some other brands, and the design options may not be as extensive as some competitors.
Atlas Shingles
Atlas Roofing Corporation manufactures various roofing products, including asphalt shingles, metal roofing, and roof underlayment. They are known for their durable products and competitive pricing. Atlas offers a range of shingle styles, including architectural shingles like Pinnacle and StormMaster. Key features include Scotchgard™ Protector for algae resistance, and some shingles designed for high-wind areas. Atlas offers a variety of warranties, depending on the specific product. While Atlas provides durable products, competitive pricing, and a focus on performance, the range of styles and colors may not be as extensive as some competitors.
TAMKO Building Products
TAMKO Building Products offers a diverse line of roofing shingles, including traditional asphalt shingles and designer shingles. They are known for their competitive pricing and their focus on providing value to homeowners. TAMKO offers a variety of shingles, including Heritage and Vista lines. They offer a variety of colors and styles and back their products with a limited warranty. While TAMKO offers affordable pricing and a good selection of colors and styles, the quality and features may not be as high as some premium brands.
Malarkey Roofing Products
Malarkey Roofing Products are known for its high-quality, innovative shingles, often considered a premium option. They utilize a unique SBS (Styrene-Butadiene-Styrene) modified asphalt technology, which provides enhanced flexibility and durability, particularly in colder climates. Malarkey offers a range of shingle styles, including architectural shingles like Legacy and Highlander. They are known for their longer-lasting shingles and offer a limited lifetime warranty on many of their products. While Malarkey provides high-quality materials, excellent durability, and innovative technology, they are more expensive than many other brands, and availability may be limited in some areas.
Top Factors to Consider When Choosing Roof Shingles
When selecting roof shingles, warranty coverage serves as a crucial indicator of product quality and manufacturer confidence. Premium shingles typically come with comprehensive warranties that protect both materials and workmanship for extended periods. These warranties not only safeguard your investment but also demonstrate the manufacturer’s commitment to product excellence. Understanding the specific terms and conditions of shingle warranties helps ensure you’re getting reliable coverage for this essential home component.
Cost considerations should extend beyond the initial purchase price to include long-term value. While premium shingles may require a larger upfront investment, they often prove more economical over time through enhanced durability, improved energy efficiency, and reduced maintenance requirements. Quality shingles can also boost your home’s resale value and minimize the need for repairs or premature replacement. Analyzing these factors helps identify the most cost-effective roofing solution that balances immediate budget constraints with long-term performance benefits.
Quality Indicators of Roof Shingles
When evaluating roof shingles, several key quality indicators stand out. First, superior durability and weather resistance are essential characteristics. Premium shingles demonstrate exceptional performance against severe weather conditions, including heavy rainfall, snow loads, high winds, and temperature extremes. The materials used in high-end shingles incorporate advanced technology for maximum protection and longevity.
Fire resistance represents another crucial quality metric, with ratings ranging from Class A to Class C. Top-tier shingles achieve Class A certification, the highest fire resistance rating available. This superior fire protection provides homeowners with enhanced safety and often leads to better insurance rates.
Energy efficiency has become increasingly important in modern roofing materials. Quality shingles now incorporate reflective technology that helps reduce heat absorption, leading to decreased cooling costs and improved home comfort. These energy-saving features can contribute to significant long-term savings while maintaining excellent protection. When choosing among various shingle options, considering these key quality indicators helps ensure you select a product that offers the best combination of protection, durability, and value for your investment.
Who Makes The Best Asphalt Shingles
At DaBella, we recommend GAF shingles as the best choice in the industry. Their track record of excellence spans over 130 years, making them North America’s largest and most trusted roofing manufacturer.
The quality of GAF’s materials is truly unmatched, particularly in their Timberline series of architectural shingles. They offer the strongest warranty in the business, covering both materials and labor, which gives our customers tremendous peace of mind. Their Advanced Protection technology provides superior durability against the elements, helping protect homes for decades.
What really sets GAF apart is their consistent commitment to quality control and innovation. Every shingle undergoes rigorous testing to ensure it meets their exacting standards. When DaBella installs GAF shingles, we know we’re providing our customers with a premium product that will protect their home and look beautiful for years to come.
FAQ’s: Best Roofing Shingles
Our most frequently asked question regarding what the best roof shingle manufacturer is.
What grade of roof shingles are best?
For most homeowners, GAF architectural shingles represent the best overall choice in roofing materials, offering a balance of durability, aesthetics, and value. These Class A shingles typically last 25-30 years, provide excellent wind and impact resistance, and create an attractive dimensional appearance that enhances curb appeal. While economy 3-tab shingles are more affordable and luxury shingles offer premium durability up to 50 years, architectural shingles hit the sweet spot for quality and cost-effectiveness. They are particularly well-suited for most climates and architectural styles, making them the go-to choice for residential roofing projects.
What are the longest lasting roof shingles?
Among roofing manufacturers, GAF, CertainTeed, and Owens Corning stand out for their premium long-lasting shingles. GAF’s Timberline HDZ and Grand Sequoia lines offer 50-year warranties, while CertainTeed’s Landmark Premium and Grand Manor collections also come with lifetime warranties extending up to 50 years. Owens Corning’s Duration and Woodmoor series provide similar 50-year protection. Malarkey’s Legacy and Vista lines are also gaining recognition for exceptional durability, featuring warranties up to 50 years. IKO’s Dynasty and Cambridge collections round out the top tier with comparable long-term protection. Keep in mind that actual shingle longevity depends heavily on proper installation, ventilation, and local weather conditions, regardless of brand.
Is Owens Corning better than GAF?
While both manufacturers offer high-quality products, GAF has established itself as the industry leader, particularly with their Timberline HDZ line. GAF shingles feature advanced technologies like their LayerLock technology and StainGuard Plus algae protection. The company also boasts the largest network of certified contractors in North America, which ensures proper installation and full warranty coverage. Their comprehensive warranty system includes options for up to 50-year coverage when installed by GAF certified contractors. Additionally, GAF’s manufacturing facilities undergo rigorous quality control processes, leading to more consistent product quality across their shingle lines.
Get a Free Quote for Your Next Roof Replacement Project!
We take pride in being a GAF Master Elite roofer, a designation that places us among the top 2% of roofing contractors in the United States. This elite status not only speaks to our commitment to quality workmanship but also allows us to offer the GAF Golden Pledge Warranty, the most comprehensive warranty in the industry. With this coverage, you can have peace of mind knowing your roof replacement is protected for years to come.
Our selection of GAF HDZ asphalt shingles is unmatched. GAF HDZ shingles are designed to withstand the harshest weather conditions while maintaining their structural integrity. Available in a wide range of colors and designs, GAF shingles allow you to customize the look of your home, ensuring that your new roof not only performs excellently but also enhances your home’s curb appeal.
Choosing the right shingles is crucial for the longevity and performance of your roof. With us, you are not just getting a roof replacement service; you are investing in quality and durability that will last. Do not wait any longer to elevate your home with the best roof shingles on the market. Contact us today at 844-DaBella for a free quote on your next roof replacement project!