GAF® Timberline® Natural Shadow Shingles

Atlas Shingles vs GAF. Which is the Best for Your Home?

9 minutes

In the world of roofing materials, two major players consistently emerge as top choices for homeowners and contractors alike: Atlas Roofing Shingles and GAF Roofing Shingles. Both companies have established themselves as industry leaders, offering a wide array of options in terms of style, durability, and affordability. As a homeowner considering investing in a new roofing system, comparing the features and benefits of Atlas and GAF shingles is a critical step in making an informed decision on which will be the best roofing manufacture shingle for your home and your budget. In this article, we will delve into the key differences between these two popular brands to help you determine which one best suits your needs and preferences.  

While both Atlas and GAF shingles are known for their quality and reliability, they each have distinct features that set them apart. We will dive deep into each of these manufacturers strengths and weaknesses to help youmake a more informed decision. From the materials used, to warranty coverage, and even environmental impact, every aspect plays a vital role in the overall performance and longevity of your roof. By thoroughly assessing the attributes of each roofing option, you will be able to confidently choose the right shingle brand for your home and enjoy the lasting benefits it provides. 

GAF vs Atlas, Which one is Right for You?

GAF and Atlas roofing manufacturers are both well known for the quality and reliability of their products. However, despite their similarities, they both do carry unique advantages and drawbacks that can influence your final decision. As you consider your options, it is essential to examine factors such as the performance of the shingles under various weather conditions, the availability of assorted styles and colors, warranties, and the overall cost of each system. We will also discuss both GAF as well as Atlas top-of-the-line roofing shingles that they both provide, and which should be the ideal choice for your home. By taking the time to compare these factors and make a well-informed decision, you can ensure the long-term protection, durability, and curb appeal of your new roof. 

Your choice will come down to weighing these factors against one another, and determining which roofing brand truly aligns with your specific home requirements and personal preferences.

Styles & Options

When comparing the specific product lines of Atlas and GAF shingles, it’s crucial to evaluate the various styles, colors, and additional features offered by each manufacturer. Both companies present a multitude of options that cater to a wide range of homeowner preferences, showcasing their commitment to quality and design.  

The most significant drawback in Atlas shingles is that they are primarily available in a 3-tab design, which may be limiting in terms of aesthetics and customization options. However, they do offer their asphalt shingles in a slate or wood shake appearance, providing homeowners with some flexibility in their design choices. On the other hand, GAF boasts a broader selection of styles, including architectural, designer, and 3-tab shingles, allowing for even greater versatility when it comes to personalizing roof design. From the standpoint of variety and available options, GAF has a slight edge over Atlas in accommodating the diverse needs and preferences of homeowners.

By examining the visual appeal and additional functionalities of each shingle, you can easily identify those that best align with your personal style and the architectural needs of your home. Furthermore, selecting a style and color that complements your home’s exterior can enhance its curb appeal, ensuring that your investment increases both your home’s aesthetic and overall value. 

Performance & Energy Efficiency

GAF and Atlas both offer shingles with reflective properties that can help to reflect more sunlight and reduce heat absorption by the roof. These reflective shingles are typically referred to as “cool” or “reflective” shingles and are often rated by the Cool Roof Rating Council (CRRC) for their solar reflectance and thermal emittance properties. The higher the solar reflectance and thermal emittance values, the more reflective and energy-efficient the shingles are considered to be. 

GAF and Atlas also offer shingles with other energy-efficient features, such as advanced insulation technology, which can help to improve the overall thermal performance of the roof and reduce heat transfer. Additionally, proper installation and ventilation of the shingles can also play a significant role in the overall energy performance of the roof.

Warranties Offered

Atlas roofing manufacturer warranty called the StormMaster Slate Signature Select Roofing system warranty offers 20 years of coverage. This type of warranty is their top of the line. 

In contrast, GAF provides their Golden Pledge 50-year non-prorated warranty on their shingles, which is also transferrable to the next owner should you decide to sell your home. This comprehensive warranty coverage includes their algae warranty term which has a warranty for 10 years for StainGuard-labeled shingles, 25 years for StainGuard Plus-labeled shingles and ridge cap shingles, and 30 years for StainGuard Plus PRO™-labeled shingles. GAF has such extensive warranty protection that they demonstrate their confidence in the quality and reliability of their products with certainty. 

When comparing the warranties offered by Atlas and GAF, it becomes clear that GAF provides more comprehensive coverage for a longer duration. This level of protection can give homeowners peace of mind, knowing that their investment in a high-quality roofing system will be well-protected against potential issues. With the added benefit of transferability, GAF’s warranty coverage can also prove to be an attractive selling point for homeowners planning to put their property on the market. 

Cost Differences

The cost difference between these two manufacturers will heavily depend on what line of shingle as well as the warranty coverage being used. As a general rule, higher-end shingle lines with more extensive warranty options will come with a higher price tag. Therefore, it’s essential for homeowners to carefully weigh their priorities, such as aesthetics, energy efficiency, and long-term protection, against their budgetary constraints when selecting a shingle product from either Atlas or GAF. By carefully considering these factors, homeowners can make a well-informed decision that provides the desired look and performance for their homes while staying within their financial means. 

Atlas Pinnacle Pristine vs GAF Timberline HDZ Shingles

GAF Timberline HDZ shingles feature innovative technology, including LayerLock™ Technology, which mechanically fuses the common bond between overlapping shingle layers. This results in a stronger bond and powers the StrikeZone™, the industry’s widest nailing area. The StrikeZone™ offers up to 99.9% nailing accuracy, making it incredibly easy for installation crews to hit their target, as evidenced by a test where 999 out of 1,000 nails were placed correctly. Additionally, the StrikeZone™ nailing area is up to 30% larger than industry standards, allowing for faster nail fastening. The legendary Dura Grip™ sealant pairs with the smooth microgranule surface of the StrikeZone™ nailing area for fast tack, and the asphalt-to-asphalt monolithic bond cures for durability, strength, and exceptional wind uplift performance. Furthermore, GAF Timberline HDZ shingles come with the WindProven™ Limited Wind Warranty, which offers an industry first: a wind warranty with no maximum wind speed limitation. 

GAF Timberline HDZ shingles are backed by a robust array of colors that will be sure to enhance the aesthetic appeal of any home. Homeowners have the flexibility to choose from a wide variety of shades, ensuring they find the perfect match for their house’s architectural style and exterior color scheme. The availability of diverse color options allows homeowners to seamlessly blend their new roofing system into the existing design of their property, providing an attractive and cohesive appearance. With GAF Timberline HDZ shingles, not only do homeowners get superior performance and wind protection, but they also benefit from a visually stunning and customizable roofing solution. 

Atlas Pinnacle® Pristine architectural shingles offer a wide range of beautiful color options that can complement your home’s exterior. These shingles are backed by the power of Scotchgard™ Protector and a 130 mph wind limited warranty, providing coverage against damage from winds up to 130 mph and ensuring that your Pinnacle® Pristine roof will stay beautiful and perform exceptionally for years to come. To provide homeowners with the most accurate representation of color options, multiple photo scans and house shots were utilized in various lighting conditions to showcase the color gradients on asphalt shingle roofs.

One of the standout features of Atlas Pinnacle® Pristine shingles is their innovative technology, which includes copper-containing granules with a proprietary 3M porous ceramic coating. These granules release copper ions slowly over time, helping to prevent the formation of black streaks caused by algae, and keeping your roof looking newer for longer, maintaining its beauty for years to come. With a combination of high performance and lasting beauty, Atlas Pinnacle® Pristine shingles are a top choice for homeowners seeking quality and aesthetics in their roofing material.  

Which is the Best Roofing Manufacturer for Your Home? GAF or Atlas?

Both Atlas and GAF are reputable roofing shingle manufacturers with their own strengths and weaknesses. Atlas offers limited style options but has a 20-year warranty, while GAF has a wider range of styles, a longer warranty of 50 years, and transferable coverage. GAF also has better energy-efficient features. The cost will depend on the specific shingle line and warranty chosen. Ultimately, the best choice for a home’s roofing shingles will depend on individual preferences and budget considerations. 

As a GAF Master Elite Contractor, DaBella has the training and expertise to offer homeowners the best shingles in the industry backed by industry leading warranties, options and colors that improve curb appeal while also improving energy efficiency and comfort. 

Are you Ready to Transform Your Home With DaBella & GAF?

Choosing the right roofing materials is a crucial decision that can impact your home’s appearance, durability, and overall value. With DaBella and GAF, homeowners can expect a seamless installation experience, as our team of professionals work diligently to ensure your satisfaction every step of the way. The combination of exceptional products and unparalleled service make DaBella and GAF a smart choice for discerning homeowners who demand quality and performance. Don’t settle for less; invest in a stunning and durable roofing solution that will elevate your home’s curb appeal while providing long-lasting protection against the elements. 

Contact DaBella today at 844-DaBella to schedule a consultation with one of our experienced roofing specialists. We will help you explore the various options available from GAF, guiding you towards the best decision for your specific needs and preferences. By partnering with DaBella, you can be confident in your roofing investment, knowing that quality and customer satisfaction are our top priorities. Don’t delay; give your home the protection and aesthetic appeal it deserves with a beautifully crafted roof from DaBella and GAF. 


Read more articles.

Steven Shortridge

District Manager

Portland, OR

Learn more about Steven