GAF Solar Shingles

GAF Solar Shingles vs Tesla Shingles

11 minutes

Solar shingles have emerged as a fusion of traditional roofing and modern solar technology in sustainable energy. Two giants leading this innovation are Tesla and GAF. 

Tesla, under the visionary guidance of Elon Musk, has always been at the forefront of sustainable energy solutions, be it through electric vehicles, battery storage, or solar energy products. The company’s foray into solar roofing, with its Solar Roof tiles, is a testament to its commitment to creating integrated renewable energy solutions for everyday homeowners. Not just content with revolutionizing the automobile industry, Tesla aims to make households energy-independent, turning homes into power stations that are both efficient and aesthetically pleasing. 

On the other hand, GAF, a company with over a century of roofing experience, is not traditionally seen as a tech-forward firm like Tesla. Yet, recognizing the shift towards sustainability and the growing demand for integrated home energy solutions, GAF introduces their own solar shingles. Their rich heritage in roofing gave them a unique vantage point, allowing them to blend their expertise in durable roofing materials with cutting-edge solar technology. 

Both companies, coming from diverse backgrounds, have recognized the immense potential of solar shingles. For Tesla, it is a logical extension of their eco-friendly ecosystem, while for GAF, it is an evolution from traditional roofing to modern, energy-generating solutions. The competition between Tesla and GAF in the solar shingle space promises advancements in technology and design, benefiting consumers and the planet.  

GAF Timberline Solar Shingles 

GAF, an established name in roofing with over a century of experience, has always been known for its quality and durability. Recognizing the global shift towards sustainability and the increasing demand for integrated home energy solutions, GAF introduced the Timberline Solar Shingles. 

The Timberline Solar Shingles represent GAF’s venture into combining traditional roofing aesthetics with modern solar technology. Unlike typical solar panel installations that sit atop existing roofs, these solar shingles are designed to integrate seamlessly with GAF’s architectural asphalt roofs, ensuring a cohesive and aesthetically pleasing appearance. This design ensures homeowners can harness solar energy without compromising on the visual appeal of their homes. 

GAF’s extensive background in roofing materials gives them a unique advantage. The Timberline Solar Shingles are not only efficient in generating electricity but are also built to endure various weather conditions, guaranteeing longevity akin to their traditional roofing counterparts. 

In essence, GAF’s Timberline Solar Shingles are a testament to the company’s commitment to evolving with the times, merging their long-standing roofing expertise with the demands of sustainable energy solutions for the modern homeowner. 

Tesla Solar Shingles 

Tesla, a brand synonymous with innovation in sustainable energy and transportation, has ventured beyond electric vehicles and battery storage solutions to redefine how we harness solar energy. Under the leadership of Elon Musk, Tesla introduced its Solar Roof tiles, commonly referred to as Tesla Solar Shingles. 

These shingles represent a revolutionary shift in solar technology. Unlike traditional bulky solar panels, Tesla’s Solar Shingles are designed to serve as both a roof and a solar energy system, integrating seamlessly into the architecture of a home. This design philosophy ensures that homeowners can produce clean energy without sacrificing aesthetic appeal. 

Beyond their sleek appearance, these shingles encapsulate Tesla’s commitment to efficiency and durability. Built with tempered glass, they are more than three times stronger than standard roofing tiles, yet they are almost indistinguishable from traditional roofing when viewed from the street. 

Tesla’s introduction of the Solar Shingles not only underscores its ambition to spearhead a global transition to sustainable energy but also its vision to integrate clean energy solutions seamlessly into our daily lives. In essence, with these shingles, Tesla is blurring the lines between functional design and sustainable innovation, turning rooftops into silent powerhouses. 

What Sets These Two Brands Apart?  


When comparing GAF’s Timberline solar shingles to Tesla’s Solar Roof, several distinguishing factors set them apart. Here are some of the primary differences and unique selling points of GAF Timberline solar shingles: 

  • Heritage and Expertise: GAF has over a century of experience in roofing, and their Timberline series has been among the best-selling roofing products in North America. Their deep-rooted knowledge in roofing provides them with insights into durability, weather resistance, and installation nuances that a newer entrant like Tesla might not possess at the outset. 
  • Integration with Traditional Roofing: While both products aim for seamless integration, GAF’s approach ensures compatibility with its popular Timberline shingles. Homeowners replacing a portion of their roof with solar shingles might find GAF’s product blending more naturally with existing non-solar shingles. 
  • Certified Installers: GAF emphasizes the importance of certified installers for their products, including DaBella, a GAF Master Elite Contractor. Given their long-standing presence in the roofing market, they have an extensive network of certified contractors who are trained specifically in the nuances of GAF installations. 
  • Pricing and Market Position: Historically, GAF has positioned its products to be more accessible to a broader range of homeowners. While specifics can vary based on region and installation, GAF might offer a more competitive price point compared to Tesla, especially when considering the broader roofing project’s cost. 
  • Warranty and Trust: Given GAF’s long-standing reputation in the roofing industry, many homeowners might find comfort in the familiar warranty structures and the established trust in the brand. 
  • Monitoring Performance: GAF’s Timberline solar shingles are accompanied by a monitoring app, similar to Tesla’s offering, allowing users to track energy output. If preferred, these solar shingles can be paired with solar batteries, including the Tesla Powerwall.  
  • Customization and Aesthetics: While Tesla focuses heavily on a sleek, modern design, GAF’s Timberline solar shingles might offer homeowners a design more aligned with traditional roofing aesthetics, appealing to those looking for a more classic appearance. 


Tesla, a name synonymous with innovation and forward-thinking, has made waves not just in the automotive sector but also in the renewable energy space. While several companies are now delving into the solar shingle industry, Tesla has carved out a niche for itself. Here is a comprehensive breakdown of what makes Tesla’s solar offerings distinct  

  • Aesthetics: One of Tesla’s primary value propositions is the sleek, modern design of their Solar Roof. The solar tiles are designed to closely resemble conventional roofing materials, allowing them to seamlessly blend with non-solar tiles. This integration creates a uniform appearance, making it nearly impossible for the untrained eye to distinguish between solar and non-solar tiles. The emphasis here is on form and function working together. 
  • Full Integration: Unlike many other solar products, Tesla’s Solar Roof is meant to replace your entire roof, rather than being an add-on. This integrated approach not only enhances aesthetics but can also be beneficial for homes needing a roof replacement soon. 
  • Innovative Cooling: Tesla’s design allows for better airflow beneath the tiles, which can help improve the efficiency of the solar cells, as they tend to perform better at cooler temperatures. 
  • Unified Software: Tesla’s ecosystem approach means that homeowners can control and monitor their Solar Roof, Powerwall, and even their Tesla vehicles using a unified app. This integration provides a streamlined experience for the user. 
  • Reputation for Innovation: While Tesla was initially known for its electric vehicles, the company has grown into a multifaceted tech and energy giant. For many, the Tesla brand carries a reputation for cutting-edge technology and forward-thinking. 


Both solar shingle systems—GAF’s Timberline and Tesla’s Solar Roof—are engineered for durability and minimal upkeep. Thus, neither is overly demanding in terms of maintenance, though there are distinctions between the two. 

GAF’s Timberline Solar shingles are maintained much like traditional asphalt shingle roofs. Regular tasks include keeping gutters debris-free, inspecting for potential damage after severe weather, and ensuring proper insulation and ventilation. Occasionally, you might need to wash the embedded solar panels to ensure optimal performance. 

In contrast, Tesla’s Solar Roof is self-maintaining. Its sleek glass surface and the roof’s inclination allow rain to naturally cleanse away grime, dust, and miscellaneous particles. This design helps the solar tiles remain clean, preserving their energy efficiency. 

To assist homeowners, both systems are equipped with performance-monitoring apps. Should you notice any discrepancies, a visual assessment or consultation with a certified technician from either Tesla or GAF can be arranged to inspect the installation. 

 Both GAF and Tesla have designed their solar shingles to endure adverse weather. Specifically, GAF’s Timberline Solar shingles can combat winds reaching 130 mph, while Tesla’s Solar Roof is resilient against winds up to 166 mph. Furthermore, each is equipped to handle hail and possesses a Class A fire rating for added safety. 

Installation Differences 

Tesla’s solar shingles represent a holistic vision for roofing, wherein the entire roof is replaced with a combination of active solar tiles and non-active glass tiles that aesthetically match. As such, the installation process is comprehensive. The old roof is entirely removed, and Tesla’s shingles are installed with an emphasis on creating a sleek, uniform appearance. The installation often requires specialized training, given the dual function of the tiles as both a roofing material and an electricity generator. Integration with Tesla’s Powerwall and other components of the Tesla energy ecosystem might also factor into the installation process. 

On the other hand, GAF, with its long-standing history in roofing, approaches solar shingles with a solid foundation in traditional roofing practices. The GAF Timberline solar shingles are designed to integrate more seamlessly with conventional roofing materials. While certain sections of a roof can be replaced with GAF’s solar shingles, the rest can remain or be fitted with traditional shingles. This offers a degree of flexibility in installation, catering to homeowners who might not want to replace their entire roof. Given GAF’s established network of roofing professionals, the installation process is likely to align closely with traditional roofing practices, albeit with the added layer of solar integration. 

While both products aim for the seamless integration of solar technology with roofing, Tesla’s approach leans more towards a complete roof transformation. Whereas GAF’s method offers a blend of new solar technology with traditional roofing techniques. 

Warranty Information 

Tesla provides a 25-year warranty for its solar shingles, ensuring coverage for both the power production capacity of the solar cells and the integrity of the tiles. Additionally, they guarantee a 25-year leak protection. For the initial five years, Tesla assures that the solar shingles will operate at 95% of their advertised energy output. Following that period, they commit to maintaining 85% power generation for the subsequent 25 years. These warranty terms are notably competitive in the solar sector, granting homeowners a significant level of confidence in their investment. 

GAF’s Timberline Solar shingles are backed by a 25–30-year warranty, which can be extended with add-ons. Moreover, GAF guarantees a 25-year energy output, ensuring that their shingles will function at 84.8% of their initial rated output throughout the warranty period. Notably, these shingles typically perform at approximately 86% of their rated output, indicating that they maintain a marginally superior efficiency over time compared to some alternatives. While there is limited data to directly contrast the long-term energy generation of Tesla and GAF Energy solar shingles, it is reasonable to infer that both offer comparable reliability. 

Cost of Solar Shingles: GAF vs. Tesla 

While the upfront cost of Tesla’s Solar Roof might be higher than traditional solar panels (since you are also paying for a full roof replacement), potential savings from energy production, combined with the aesthetic appeal and durability, can make it an attractive option for certain homeowners. Compared to the GAF timberline solar shingles, Tesla is much more expensive.  

GAF’s timberline solar shingles do tend to be on the higher end because you are still paying for the roof replacement as well, but still tend to be much cheaper than Tesla. Are you paying for the brand name?  

Of course, the cost of installation and materials will also depend on the number of squares and your roof’s complexity.  

Reach out to Learn More About DaBella’s Roof Replacements & Solar Shingle Option 

Residents of San Diego, Sacramento, Redding, and surrounding areas: Are you ready to redefine your home’s energy and aesthetics? DaBella is proud to offer GAF’s state-of-the-art solar shingles, combining robust roof protection with cutting-edge solar technology. 

These solar shingle options allow you to merge the strength of traditional roofing with the sustainable benefits of solar power. In making the switch, you are not just upgrading your roof; you are making a forward-thinking choice for the environment and your wallet. 

Take advantage of this opportunity to be a part of this roofing revolution. Upgrade to GAF solar shingles with DaBella and lead the way in sustainable living. Contact us now and harness the future of roofing in California. 


Read more articles.

Steven Shortridge

District Manager

Portland, OR

Learn more about Steven