A Painter on a lift painting the siding on a yellow house.

Painting Old Siding vs. Replacing Siding 

8 minutes

When considering methods to enhance your home’s exterior, a critical choice arises: refresh your existing siding with a coat of paint, or invest in a complete siding replacement?  

Both options offer distinct advantages and disadvantages, affecting not just aesthetics but also durability, maintenance requirements, and your overall budget. Here, we will show you the pros and cons of each approach, addressing commonly asked questions to help you navigate this decision. We will explain factors like cost, longevity, and visual impact, equipping you to choose the method that best aligns with your home’s needs and your budget.  

The Advantages of Painting Your Siding 

Here are the advantages of painting the siding that is currently on your home.  

Small Improvement in Curb Appeal 

Thinking about sprucing up your home’s exterior? Painting your existing siding can be a fantastic option for a dramatic aesthetic improvement. A fresh coat of paint does wonders for worn-out siding, instantly enhancing your home’s curb appeal with a vibrant and refreshed look. With a wide variety of colors available on the market today, you can personalize your home’s style and boost its curb appeal by selecting the perfect shade to match your vision. 

Budget Friendliness 

Choosing to paint your siding is a budget-friendly way to significantly enhance your home’s exterior. Replacing siding, particularly for larger houses, can be a substantial investment. Painting offers a similar visual impact at a fraction of the cost, allowing you to update your home’s look without breaking the bank. 

The Benefits of a Siding Replacement 

While painting your existing siding offers a temporary refresh, replacing your siding altogether unlocks a range of long-term benefits for your home.  

Energy Efficiency Benefits 

Older siding, especially damaged or poorly insulated options, can be a major contributor to energy loss. This translates to higher utility bills throughout the year, as your heating and cooling systems work harder to maintain comfortable temperatures inside. Replacing your siding with modern materials often provides improved insulation. This can significantly reduce air infiltration, keeping warm air in during winters and cool air in during summers. The result? A more comfortable living environment and potential cost savings on your energy bills. 

Boost in Curb Appeal 

New siding can dramatically elevate your home’s exterior, giving it a fresh and modern look. With a vast array of color options, textures, and styles available, you gain the power to completely transform your home’s aesthetic. Whether you prefer a classic brick look, a contemporary woodgrain finish, or a sleek and modern fiber cement option, there is a siding material to suit your taste and architectural style.

Increased Home Value 

Siding replacement is a smart investment that can significantly increase your home’s value. Potential buyers are often drawn to homes with new siding due to several factors. First, the fresh and updated look creates a positive impression and signifies a well-maintained property. Second, new siding typically requires less maintenance than older options, saving homeowners time and money. Finally, high-quality siding materials offer greater durability and weather resistance, ensuring a longer lifespan and potentially reducing the need for future repairs down the line. All these factors combined contribute to a higher perceived value for your home in the eyes of potential buyers. 

Increased Protection from the Elements 

Over time, exposure to harsh weather elements can take a toll on your siding’s material. Older siding might become warped, cracked, or even develop mold and mildew growth. Replacing your siding with modern materials ensures improved durability and weather resistance. This not only protects your home’s exterior from the elements but also provides peace of mind knowing your investment is safeguarded against potential damage.  

At DaBella, we offer a wide variety of premium siding options that are durable, low-maintenance, and designed to enhance your home’s curb appeal and energy efficiency. Reach out to us today to learn more about our vinyl siding and fiber cement siding.  

Drawbacks of Replacing Your Siding 

While a brand-new siding can elevate your home’s aesthetics and value, replacing your existing siding is not a decision to take lightly. Here are some drawbacks to consider before diving in: 

Cost: This is the biggest hurdle. Replacing siding is a significant financial investment. Material costs vary depending on the type of siding you choose (vinyl, fiber cement, wood, etc.), and the size of the home. Also, a professional installation adds another layer of expense. 

Disruption: The siding replacement process can be disruptive. It can take several days or even a week depending on the size and complexity of your house. You might need to relocate outdoor furniture and may need to relocate plants around the home.  

Unexpected Issues: Sometimes, hidden problems can be discovered during the removal of your old siding. This could be rot, water damage, or even structural issues requiring additional repairs and potentially pushing up the overall project cost.  

Selecting the Best Option for Your Home 

Deciding between painting old siding vs replacing siding can significantly impact your home’s appearance and value. Key factors to consider include budget, project timeline, and professional advice. 

Painting is more affordable than replacing siding and can be a good choice if you are on a tight budget. But if your siding is showing signs of needing a replacement it may be the most cost-effective solution.  

Signs your Home Needs New Siding 

  • Visible Damage: This is the most obvious sign. Look for cracks, chips, warping, bulging, or holes in your siding panels. These can compromise the siding’s ability to protect your home from the elements and may allow moisture infiltration. 
  • Rot or Mold Growth: If you see any signs of rot, especially on wood siding, it is a clear indication that moisture is getting behind the siding and causing damage. Mold or mildew growth on the siding’s surface can also be a sign of moisture issues and potential underlying problems. 
  • Paint Problems: Frequent peeling, chipping, or blistering of paint can indicate problems with the underlying siding or improper preparation before painting. This could be due to moisture issues or incompatibility between the paint and the siding material. 
  • Increased Energy Bills: Older or damaged siding can be less effective at insulating your home. This can lead to drafts, uneven temperatures inside, and, higher energy bills to maintain comfortable temperatures. 
  • Signs of Infestation: If you see any signs of insects like carpenter ants or termites around your siding, it could be a sign that they are using the siding as a nesting ground. Damaged or compromised siding can provide entry points for these pests. 
  • Age of Your Siding: Even if you do not see any visible damage, the lifespan of different siding materials varies. For example, vinyl siding typically lasts 20-40 years, while wood siding might need replacement every 10-20 years depending on maintenance. If your siding is nearing the end of its expected lifespan, it might be wise to consider a replacement before problems arise. 

Consulting with a professional is always beneficial. They can assess your siding’s condition and provide tailored advice. 

FAQs: Painting vs. Replacing Siding 

Here are some commonly asked questions on this topic. 

Can new siding be installed over old siding?  

While technically possible to install new siding directly over your existing siding, it is not recommended. This is because the old siding could hide underlying problems like moisture damage, rot, or insect infestation. Removing the old siding allows for a thorough inspection and any necessary repairs before the new layer goes on. This ensures a healthier foundation for your new siding, maximizing its lifespan and preventing potential issues down the road.  

Is replacing siding worth it?  

Absolutely! Replacing your siding offers a trifecta of benefits. The fresh, updated look it provides can dramatically enhance your home’s curb appeal, making it stand out on the block. Additionally, new siding is often more energy-efficient, potentially lowering your utility bills. And lastly, this upgrade can significantly increase your home’s value, making it a popular option if you are looking for a high ROI investment. 

What are the downsides of painting vinyl siding?  

Painting vinyl siding can be tricky. The paint may not adhere well due to the vinyl’s smooth surface and potential for expansion and contraction in hot and cold weather. This can lead to peeling, cracking, and a shorter lifespan for the paint job. 

Choose DaBella for Your Siding Replacement Needs 

As a James Hardie Elite Preferred contractor, DaBella is your go-to choice for siding replacement. Our team offers exceptional siding options, including James Hardie Fiber cement siding and vinyl siding, which provide numerous benefits for your home. Contact DaBella today at 844-DaBella to discuss your siding replacement project. Our team is here to answer your questions, provide a free consultation, and guide you towards the best decision for your home. 

Steven Shortridge

District Manager

Portland, OR

Learn more about Steven