GAF® Camelot® Welsh HDZ Grey Shingles

Metal vs. Shingle Roofs

13 minutes

Doing your due diligence in making an informed decision is an essential part of any successful roofing replacement project. Weighing the pros and cons of each type of roofing material is a suitable place to start. Here, we take a close look at two of the most popular types of roofing on the market today: metal roofs and shingle roofs. By the time you finish reading, you should have a much better idea as to which type of material is right for you and your home. 

Let us explore the key differences between these two types of roofing to help you make an informed decision for your home or business. Metal roofs are made from a variety of metals and alloys including steel, aluminum, and copper. Asphalt shingles are made from a fiberglass mat that is coated with asphalt and then covered with ceramic granules. 

Metal Roofing vs. Asphalt: Pros & Cons of Each 

Here are the pros and cons of both Metal Roofing and Shingle Roofs

Metal Roofing Benefits & Advantages 

Metal roofs have a longer lifespan than many other roofing materials, making them a great choice for any homeowner looking to save money in the long run. They are also exceptionally durable and can withstand extreme weather events, making them an excellent option for homeowners in hurricane and tornado-prone areas. Plus, metal roofs are environmentally friendly and help reduce energy bills. All these factors make metal roofs a great choice for any homeowner looking for a long-lasting and reliable roofing material. 

Very Little Maintenance 

One of the biggest advantages of a metal roof is that it requires little maintenance. Once a metal roof is installed, you can expect it to last for decades with little upkeep. It may require an annual cleaning of debris. However, you will want to stay vigilant to make sure that there is no warping in this type of roofing material during the summer months.  

Options and Styles 

One of the great advantages of a metal roof is that it comes in a variety of styles and colors. You can choose from a wide range of metal roofing materials including steel, aluminum, and copper. The remarkable thing about metal roofing is that it can be painted whatever color you would like. Giving the homeowner more control over the appearance and aesthetic of their home. 

Return on Investment 

One of the biggest advantages of a metal roof is its lifespan. Metal roofs can last up to 50 years. This makes a metal roof a wise investment for any homeowner looking to save money in the long run. This could also be a selling point for home buyers as they will not have to worry about replacing the roof for the foreseeable future.  

Excellent Durability 

Metal roofs are also exceptionally durable and can withstand high winds and hail damage. This makes them an excellent choice for homeowners in hurricane and tornado-prone areas. Metal roofs are also fire resistant, which is an important consideration for any homeowner. Metal roofs are non-combustible and will not ignite in the event of a fire. This could be a huge selling point for home buyers who are looking for a home in a fire-prone area.  

Environmentally Friendly Material 

Metal roofs are also an environmentally friendly roofing material. Most metal roofs are made from recycled materials. This makes them a wonderful choice for homeowners who are looking to be more eco-conscious. Metal roofs are also 100% recyclable at the end of their lifespan. It is also an excellent choice for lowering your energy bills. Metal roofs reflect heat, which helps keep your home cooler in the summer. This can lead to lower energy bills and a smaller carbon footprint.  

Longer Lifespan Than Many Other Roofing Materials 

Metal roofs have a longer lifespan than many other roofing materials. This makes them a great investment for any homeowner who is looking for a long-term solution. The lifespan of metal roofs can be as long as 50 years, which is significantly longer than that of asphalt roofs, which typically last around 30 years. Additionally, metal roofs are much more durable and can withstand high winds, hail, and heavy rain, making them an excellent choice for areas prone to extreme weather. 

Cons of Metal Roofing 

Of course, metal roofs do come with some drawbacks. They can be more expensive than other roofing materials, such as asphalt shingles. Additionally, metal roofs can be noisy during heavy rain or a hailstorm. There is also a dwindling decline in experienced metal roofing installers. Metal roofing is known as a very labor-intensive replacement job and requires a lot of time and precision. Oil canning is also prevalent. We will discuss below what this is and how it may or may not affect your roof. Also, homeowner associations and insurance companies are not too keen on metal roofing.  

Metal Roof Installers are Dropping 

Although metal roofs have their advantages, they can be difficult to install and require a specialized set of skills. It is important to ensure the installer is experienced in metal roofing, as improper installation can lead to various problems in the future. Unfortunately, there are fewer and fewer experienced metal roofers in the field, so it is important to do your research when looking for an installer.  

Oil Canning 

Another potential issue with standing seam metal roofs is oil canning. Oil canning is the result of metal roofing panels that have either moved, changed, or experienced an event that has changed the shape. This will make your metal roof look wavy or a ripple in boards. This is mostly a cosmetic issue and should not affect the performance of the roof. Unfortunately, when oil canning happens there is not much you can do to combat this.  

Cost of Labor 

Labor for installing a replacement metal roof is quite intensive. It can take up to three times longer to install a metal roof than other roofing materials. This is due to the precision required for a successful installation. It is also important to note that not all roofers are experienced in metal roofing, and it is essential to find someone who is experienced if you are considering a metal roof. If not installed correctly by a professional metal roofer, it can cause some dire consequences to your home.  

HOA Issues 

Homeowner associations can be extremely strict on the type of roofing material that you can use for your home. They may not allow you to install a metal roof if everyone else in your neighborhood has a shingle roof. This means if you want to install a metal roof, you may have to work with your HOA to ensure it has been approved.  

Insurance Premiums 

Insurance companies tend to increase insurance premiums for homes that have metal roofs. This is because metal roofs are more expensive than most other types of roofing, and therefore more costly to replace. Insurance companies also look at the history of metal roofs, as they tend to be more prone to damage in certain weather conditions. In areas that are prone to extreme weather conditions, insurance companies may not be willing to provide coverage for metal roofs. Homeowners should be aware of this before they decide to install a metal roof, as it could lead to unexpected expenses down the road that your insurance company may not cover. 

Noise Levels are Significant 

Metal roofs can be very noisy during heavy rain or hailstorms, and this can be a major problem for some homeowners. If you are considering a metal roof, it is important to make sure that you are prepared for the increased noise levels that come with it. In some cases, the noise level can be so loud that it can wake you up at night or make it difficult to concentrate during the day.  

Shingle Roof Benefits and Advantages 

Asphalt shingle roofs are the most popular roofing material in the United States. In fact, about 80% of all roofs in the United States are asphalt shingles. Shingle roofs are much easier to install, and they can be installed in a fraction of the time compared to metal roofs. Additionally, they are much cheaper than metal roofs, making them a more affordable option for homeowners. They also come in a variety of colors and styles, so you can customize your roof to fit the style of your home. Lastly, shingle roofs do not require much maintenance and are relatively easy to repair, making them a great long-term solution for any home.  

Easy to Install 

Replacement asphalt shingles are by far one of the easiest types of roofing materials to install. Although they should still be installed by a professional with plenty of experience, they are quite simple to replace.  

Ease of Maintenance  

Asphalt shingles require extraordinarily little maintenance and are easy to repair if they become damaged or worn down. They are much less susceptible to damage from storms and high winds than metal roofs and can last for many years with proper maintenance. Furthermore, if any shingles are broken or missing, they can be easily replaced. This makes them a great type of roofing for any homeowner looking for an affordable and reliable roofing material. 

Best Economical Option for Sloped Roofs 

Asphalt shingle roofs are by far the best economical option for sloped roofs when it comes to both installation and maintenance. They are much easier to install and require little to no maintenance when compared to metal roofs. They are the perfect choice for most homeowners looking for a roof that is both reliable and affordable. 

Finding an Asphalt Shingle Contractor is Easy 

Finding the right contractor to install an asphalt shingle roof is also quite easy. Most roofers are experienced in installing this type of roof and can guide you through the process. Additionally, most roofers offer warranties for the installation of their roofs, which can give you peace of mind. With the right professional, asphalt shingle roofs can last for many years and provide your home with the protection it needs. 

DaBella is regarded as the top performing roofing contractor in the United States, according to Qualified Remodelers annual Top 500 Rankings. We are also recognized as a GAF Master Elite Contractor providing excellent workmanship to homeowners across the US (United States) with industry leading warranties. 

Large Quantity of Styles & Options 

Our Partners at GAF Roofing materials provide a long range of styles and colors to choose from. As a GAF Master Elite contractor, we have been able to provide our customers with exclusive colors to set your home apart from the rest. Our design consultants will help you choose the perfect color scheme to complement your home’s exterior. You can be confident that your new roof will be installed by a team of factory-trained installers and backed by one of the best warranties in the industry.

Fire Protection  

Every GAF roof comes with the GAF VeraShield technology that makes your roof decking fire resistant. This is a key factor for many homeowners, as it can provide extra protection for your home and your family in the event of a fire. With GAF’s quality materials and experienced installers, you can be sure that your new roof will last for many years to come.  

Cons of Asphalt Roofing 

While asphalt shingles are a wonderful choice for many homeowners, there are some drawbacks. Asphalt shingles do not last as long as metal roofs, and they are not as heat resistant. Asphalt roofs are still a great option for most homeowners looking for an affordable and reliable roofing option. 


Metal roofs are known to last much longer than asphalt shingles. The more expensive option, metal roofs can last up to 50-100 years with proper maintenance. However, asphalt shingle roofs last about 30 years with proper care.  

Heat Resistance 

When contemplating roofing materials, it’s pivotal to consider their heat resistance, particularly in areas subject to prolonged high temperatures. While metal roofs tout superior heat resistance over asphalt shingles, it’s noteworthy that asphalt shingles offer their own merits in heat management. Thanks to their granular composition, asphalt shingles enhance the reflectiveness of the sun’s rays, effectively mitigating heat absorption and maintaining cooler indoor temperatures. Properly installed and ventilated asphalt shingle roofs can adeptly counteract heat retention, ensuring your home remains comfortable even amidst scorching weather conditions.

While metal roofs may excel in enduring extreme temperatures, asphalt shingles present a practical and budget-friendly alternative for homeowners keen on efficient heat management and safeguarding against the sun’s intensity. By leveraging the granules embedded within asphalt shingles, homeowners can capitalize on their innate ability to regulate temperatures and foster a more comfortable living environment, making them a compelling choice for roofing solutions in regions prone to heatwaves.

Metal Roofing vs. Shingle Costs 

The cost of a new roof is one of the biggest factors that homeowners need to consider when selecting a roofing material. Generally, metal roofs cost much more upfront than asphalt shingles, but they can last much longer and require less maintenance. Asphalt shingles are more affordable and can be replaced more easily making tear off costs much lower as well. Ultimately, the roofing material you choose should be based on your budget and the intended lifespan of the roof. 

Which is the Best Type of Roofing Material for Your Home?  

In the end, the decision between metal and asphalt shingles comes down to personal preference, budget, and the climate of your location. Metal roofs may be more expensive, but they are an excellent choice for those looking for a roof that will last for many decades to come. On the other hand, asphalt shingles are a much more cost-effective and low-maintenance option that can provide your home with reliable protection for many years if installed correctly and is well maintained. No matter which type of roof you choose, make sure to do your research, get an experienced contractor such as DaBella for your next project asphalt roofing project.  

Contact DaBella Today for Your Next Asphalt Roof Replacement Project 

At DaBella, we have the expertise and customer service you need to ensure that your asphalt roofing replacement project is a success. Our experienced team of professionals will guide you through the entire roof installation process, from selecting the right roofing materials to the completion of the installation. We offer competitive pricing, top-of-the-line materials, and outstanding customer service that cannot be beat. Contact DaBella today at 844-DaBella to find out how we can help you get the roof of your dreams and the transformation your home deserves. 


Read more articles.

Steven Shortridge

District Manager

Portland, OR

Learn more about Steven